Critical Opalescence in Carbon Dioxide

One feature of the teaching at Dalhousie University’s Physics Department is a laudable emphasis on demonstrations.

Visiting Professor Tom Duck there, I was delighted to be shown a demonstration I had heard of, but never seen: the phenomenon of critical opalescence in carbon dioxide.

I have written about critical opalescence previously on this blog (here) and with more pictures (here), so I won’t repeat most of that.

In my previous articles I described the phenomenon in two immiscible liquids which is an exact analogy for the physics of critical opalescence in a pure substance. But it’s not what physics students read about in text books.

Michael: What are you going on about?

The phenomenon occurs when one heats a liquid in a container with a small amount of free space.

  • As the liquid heats up, it expands causing its density to fall.
  • The liquid also evaporates causing the vapour (gas) pressure to increase.
  • The critical point is where the density of the liquid matches that of the vapour.

Above this ‘critical’ temperature and pressure, the substance forms a single fluid with no distinct liquid state. In the movie you can see that the meniscus at the top of the liquid just gradually disappears – there is now no ‘surface tension’.

At the critical point, the density of the fluid is typically one third of the liquid density at atmospheric pressure. Because there is no difference between liquid and gas, the latent heat associated with evaporation (when molecules move from the liquid to the gas) and condensation (when molecules move from the gas to the liquid) falls to zero.

Critical Opalescence can be seen when cooling just below the critical temperature.

The random motion of the molecules in the fluid causes some regions to transiently have densities that are slightly greater than the average (more typical of the liquid) – and others to have densities more typical of the gas.

Because the latent heat and the surface tension are very close to zero, these microscopic fluctuations can grow dramatically. Spontaneous fluctuations can cause regions as large as a thousandth of a millimetre – containing thousands of billions of molecules -to fluctuate into and out of the liquid state – forming droplets.

Although the difference in density (and hence refractive index) between the liquid droplets and the gas is tiny – it is just enough to scatter light – like a fog – a phenomenon which someone poetically named ‘opalescence’ rather than fog.

Critical Opalescence is mentioned in Physics course, but  it is rarely seen. The high pressures involved (more than 73 atmospheres in this case) present a hazard that few people are prepared to tackle. I suspect that students at Dalhousie may not appreciate how lucky they are!


P.S. It turns out that carbon dioxide above its critical point is an excellent non-toxic solvent for caffeine and so when you sip your de-caff latte tomorrow – you can now imagine the physics that describes the fluid which took away the caffeine.


Tags: , ,

3 Responses to “Critical Opalescence in Carbon Dioxide”

  1. telescoper Says:

    Reblogged this on In the Dark and commented:
    Fascinating demonstration of critical opalescence..

  2. Michael Kane Says:

    This used to be a demonstration in the London Science museum. You could find it at the back of the museum on the top floor in a slightly forgotten part of the museum in the seventies. The last time I visited the museum about ten years ago this part was closed off. I remember being fascinated by watching it. It exactly as seen in the video.

  3. Giuliano Gavazzi Says:

    We were lucky enough to perform this experiment in the early 80s in the Physics Department of Turin Univ.
    But this is not the reason I am here. I could not remember the name of that young physicist who was kind enough to let me study and write on an article in a library long time ago, until after a search on Do you remember Michael? (I would write elsewhere but I cannot find a contact link!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: