A carbon neutral gym?

Is it feasible to make a 'carbon neutral' gym?

Is it feasible to make a 'carbon neutral' gym?

My colleagues Laurie and Andrew have just recovered from producing NPL’s blockbusting ‘Energy Harvesting’ stand at the Royal Society’s Summer Exhibition. And last week they asked me whether it was possible to have a carbon neutral gym? The idea must have occurred to many people as they sweat and struggle. Surely, they think , all this effort is not entirely pointless? Surely we could capture some this work being done and use it to power the lights? Surely if Seattle can have 20 carbon neutral office blocks, we manage a gym! Well, let’s see.

Let’s look at the power 20 squad members in a Rugby team training together might produce.

  • Rowing Machines: If I try hard I can generate 150 W of power on a rowing machine for around 10 minutes. Let’s assume rugby players can generate for 250 W for 15 minutes. If we had 5 machines then we could rotate banks of 5 players through these machines to generate a continuous 5 x 250 = 1250 W – that’s impressive .
  • Treadmills: A treadmill actually consumes energy :-(, and a typical device might have a 2 horse power (1500 W) motor. So either we could have 6 rowing machines powering one treadmill, or more sensibly, we could just abandon treadmills and get the team to run around a Rugby pitch.
  • Exercise bikes: I don’t have a figure for bikes, but in my experience they are less knackering than rowing so I would guess they can generate less energy. Let’s guess we have 5 exercise bikes and each one can generate 150 W then we could rotate banks of 5 players through these machines to generate a continuous 5 x 150 = 750 W.
  • Cross Trainers: I don’t have a figure for cross-trainers (sometimes called elliptical trainers),  but in my experience they are less knackering than rowing but more knackering than exercise bikes, so I would guess they can generate power somewhere in between the previous two. Let’s guess we have 5 cross-trainers and each one can generate 200 W then we could rotate banks of 5 players through these machines to generate a continuous 5 x 200 = 1000 W.

So with 5 of each type of cardio machine and no treadmills, 15 rugby players could generate 1250 W + 750 W + 1000 W = 3000W – a useful amount of power. Each person would be working at a rate which would burn roughly 1000 kCal/hour which is pretty intense exercise, so let’s guess that they could do this for one hour.

  • Muscle Machines: In these machines pulleys translate the physical motion into a lift of some weights, typically by about half a metre. Let’s assume that each lift is of 40 kg, then each lift requires (m x g x h) (40 x 10 x 0.5) 200 Joules of energy. If we could capture this in a way that generated electricity, and  a lift was performed on average every second (assuming several people are exercising simultaneously) then that could generate 200 W of power.

Is it feasible: Given these simple calculations the answer has to be – ‘Yes’. But there are caveats

  • In general one can’t capture all the energy people dissipate in these machines. Dynamos are not ideally efficient and the muscle machines would not couple easily to dynamos; some players may not be ideally fit; and we have assumed 100% occupancy of the equipment. So in practice our 3000 W of power would be substantially reduced, but 1000 W would be a fair estimate.
  • Human’s generate heat when they exert themselves – about 6 times more than work they produce. So if 3000 W of work is being produced there would be an astonishing 18 kW of heat produced – so some kind of cooling or ventilation would be required – which would take energy. Let’s assume this is negligible and that we cool using a chimney effect.
  • The gym would need to have a relatively large floor area which would probably require lighting – which would probably require several hundred watts  – but let’s ignore this and assume the training is in daylight.
  • Over one hour, the team would have plausibly generated 1 kWh of useful electrical energy, which would have cost at most £0.25.
  • Over one day (12 hours) assuming the equipment was highly utilised, this might amount to 12 kWh of energy, which would have cost at most £3.00.
  • Over a week (5 days) this might amount to 60 kWh of energy, which would have cost at most £15.
  • Over a year this might amount to 3120 kWh of energy, which would have cost at most £780.
 So all in all: this 2.6% per annum return on investment might well make sense in the context of the £30,000 or so which such a gym might cost. Or
But would that be carbon neutral? Well No. Such a gym would not recoup the carbon released during in the manufacture of the equipment for many decades – probably beyond the lifetime of the equipment. But people might well prefer a gym where they feel their efforts aren’t being wasted. However, what would be the worst possible outcome would be that additional generating equipment was incorporated into gym equipment to make people feel better, and that the carbon cost of the additional equipment was not recouped either!
As many people have found micro-generation of electricity can make sense in certain contexts. For instance if the gym  was in an isolated location which could not connect to the electricity grid. But nothing can approach the low cost of central generation of electricity using cheap carbon-emitting fuel. If electricity from the grid was all  renewably generated lots of schemes such as this one would make economic sense. However electricity might then cost perhaps £1.00/kWh and we would all take much more care not waste a joule. Anyone in favour of massively increasing electricity prices?
Advertisements

Tags: ,

2 Responses to “A carbon neutral gym?”

  1. A carbon neutral gym? – Ask a scientist Says:

    […] question was originally posted on Michael’s blog Tweet window.fbAsyncInit = function() { FB.init({appId: '105713076143923', status: true, […]

  2. A carbon neutral gym? Says:

    […] This question was originally posted on Michael’s blog […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: